Is This The Bee Gees Finest Ever Album Cut? Barry Gibb’s 70th Birthday


Listen: scroll to the bottom of this article to hear Barry Gibb’s new single In The Now.

In 1978 the Bee Gees were at the top of their game to such an extent that it’s arguable no songwriting team has ever dominated the American music charts so completely. There were the five songs in the US top 10 at the same time, week after week. There were the mammoth hits they wrote for other artists that year like Grease (Frankie Vallie), Shadow Dancing (Andy Gibb), Emotion (Samantha Sang), If I Can’t Have You (Yvonne Elliman) and Warm Ride (Graham Bonnett).

There were the four consecutive US #1 hits – a stat often mistaken as being four in a row for the group (by 1979 they would do six), when in fact it was Gibb song at number one, replaced by a Gibb song at number one, replaced by a Gibb song at number one, replaced by a Gibb song at number one. During one eight month period beginning in December 1977, a Bee Gees song was number one 25 out of 32 weeks. Staggering.

It was within that climate of unparalleled success, where they were shifting so much vinyl that their record company had to pay rivals to manufacture more for them just to keep up with demand, that the Bee Gees set about writing the followup LP for Saturday Night Fever. 37 years on, the work they came up with Spirits Having Flown has been estimated to have sold anywhere from 15 million copies to 30 million, making it not only one of the Bee Gees biggest ever albums, but one of the biggest albums of all time.

Barry once said that in hindsight there was too much falsetto on the album, though more recently has said that the falsetto-sound was so hot at the time they couldn’t not do a falsetto album. With Fever selling a million a week and in a creative bubble where everything the Gibbs wrote sounded like a hit because invariably it was, the use of falsetto hadn’t reached its tipping point from credibility to misunderstood parody.

And when that tipping point hit, it was as if black artists who used falsetto like Earth Wind & Fire (Philip Bailey), the Temptations (Eddie Kendricks), the Delfonics, the Stylistics etc were excused, but for a white band to be so blatantly influenced by black music and R&B seemed to be confronting. At least for the predominantly white, male rock fans in America behind the racially charged “Disco Sucks” movement.

The Spirits Having Flown album produced three number one hits in Too Much Heaven, Tragedy and Love You Inside Out, but for me, it has always been the title track which has meant the most. If Spirits Having Flown the album is guilty of lacking vocal variety, Spirits Having Flown the song most certainly isn’t. Featuring breathy natural voice on the verses, assertive falsetto for the choruses and some of the most complex harmonies the group ever laid down, Spirits Having Flown stands for me as the greatest example of the genius of the Bee Gees’ production team.

While the album is officially produced by the Bee Gees, Albhy Galuten and Karl Richardson (who’d worked with the group since the mid-70s), it must also not be underestimated the ground-work of Mr Natural and Main Course producer Arif Mardin in 1974-75, nor the influence of Dennis Byron on drums, Alan Kendall on guitar and in particular, Blue Weaver on keyboards. All played a vital role in fleshing out the true potential of the songs the Bee Gees were writing. Spirits Having Flown (song) remains the zenith of the Bee Gees sound with a crack band, beautiful lyrics, harmonies and production.

As to why the production is so good, listen for the drum fills, the tension that hits in the chorus with Weaver’s synthesizer keyboards, the carry-over of the vocals at the end of the chorus: “I’d like to take you where my spirit flies, through empty skies we go alone, never before having flown,” and best of all, the fade-out.

This song stands out for me ultimately for two main reasons: the marriage of the spiritual nature of the lyrics with the melancholy of the fade-out. I once heard a documentary on BBC Radio 2 where they dissected the song’s layers and pointed out that with every bar in the fade-out a new element is added to the song. The beauty of flutes, the shuffling of the drums, the keyboard bass, the counter-melody lines of the horn-section, the background falsettos…..This isn’t just a pretty song, but a song of immense detail, carefully crafted with the precision of songsmiths at the peak of their powers.

Sometimes that perfectionism can suck the life out of songs, as it did on parts of the Eagles The Long Run album, but it rarely worked as well as it did on Spirits Having Flown.

Happy 70th birthday Barry Gibb and as every die-hard Bee Gees fan also knows, happy wedding anniversary too Barry and Linda (46 years). Enjoy my pick for the Bee Gees finest ever album cut, though there are literally dozens of contenders for that title.* And once you’re done listening to Spirits Having Flown do have a listen as well to how Barry sounds in 2016 with the title-track from his long-awaited solo album In The Now (due for release October 7).

*I’m calling Spirits Having Flown an album track because despite it being a UK top 20 hit in 1980, it went unreleased in most of the world.

A version of this article first appeared on The Roxborogh Report in 2011 for Barry’s 65th birthday.

5 Comments Add yours

  1. Anonymous says:

    There are not enough words to completely explain this Man and his family. Born genius goes close <3

  2. Anonymous says:

    Just listened to it. As good as anything he's ever done.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Barry, is left to carry the torch. It is a great CD, "In The Now." It takes great courage to record a CD alone.

  4. Anonymous says:

    Good point re this song Tim.

  5. Anonymous says:

    Good listen. He still sounds great. Oct 07 2016 12:10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.